On May 4, 1896, ground on the corner of third and St Catherine Streets in Quarryville Borough was broken. The cornerstone was placed on July 4, 1896 and Bishop Thomas McGovern dedicated the structure on November 8, 1896. The estimated cost of the building was $4,400. It was described as a 30' x 50' area with a sanctuary 18' x 18', all of brick and stone in a Romanesque style. The building has a steeple and a bell tower and could seat 250 people.